Crimea Monuments Commemorating the Civil War: Mnemonic Actors – the Warriors of Memory

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Open Access Open Access
Restricted Access Access granted
Restricted Access Subscription Access

Abstract

The article presents a study of memory politics actors, taking the case of memorialization of recollections of the Civil War in Crimea in the post-Soviet period. Drawing on a range of sources including field materials collected during the 2023–24 research trips to the cities of Crimea, I attempt to trace the process of appearance of the new monuments that were dedicated to the events and figures of the Civil War, and that were established both during the period of Crimea’s accession to Ukraine and in the period after its incorporation into Russia in 2014. I argue that among the agents that can become major actors of memory politics, apart from the state and its affiliated structures possessing the necessary administrative and financial resources, there can just as well be local activists who seek to establish their own historical narratives in the public space out of unselfish motivations not necessarily related to the ideological support of power institutions (“mnemonic warriors”). Furthermore, they can act in cooperation both with individual representatives of the state (which is not a monolithic actor) and with large social structures such as, for instance, the Russian Orthodox Church which itself acts as an independent actor of memory politics directed towards the Civil War events.

Full Text

Restricted Access

About the authors

Daria Chubukova

Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology, Russian Academy of Sciences

Author for correspondence.
Email: chubukovadaria@yandex.ru
ORCID iD: 0009-0003-8412-080X

младший научный сотрудник центра по изучению межэтнических отношений

Russian Federation, 32a Leninsky prospekt, Moscow, 119991

References

  1. Alisov, D.A., and Y.A. Zakunov, eds. 2016. Grazhdanskaia voina v Rossii (1917–1922): istoricheskaia pamiat’ i problemy memorializatsii “krasnogo” i “belogo” dvizheniia: sbornik materialov Vserossiiskoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii (Omsk, 16–17 iiunia 2016) [Civil War in Russia (1917–1922): Historical Memory and Problem of the Commemorations of the “Krasnogo” and “Belogo Movements: A Collection of Materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conferences (Omsk, 16–17 June 2016)]. Moscow: Institut Naslediia.
  2. Anikin, D.A. 2021. “Belaia armiia, chernyi baron”: interpretatsiia obraza P.N. Vrangelia v simvolicheskoi politike sovremennoi Rossii [“White Army, Black Baron”: Interpretation of the Image of P.N. Vrangel in the Symbolic Politics of Modern Russia]. In Simvolicheskie aspekty politiki pamiati v sovremennoi Rossi i Vostochnoi Evrope [Symbolic Aspects of Memory Politics in Modern Russia and Eastern Europe: Collection of Articles], edited by V.V. Lapin and A.I. Miller, 108–119. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge.
  3. Anikin, D.A., and A.Y. Bubnov. 2021. Traektorii istoricheskoi pamiati o Grazhdanskoi voine v Rossii (na primere liderov Belogo dvizheniia) [Trajectories of Historical Memory of the Civil War in Russia (The Example of the Leaders of the White Movement P.N. Wrangel and A.V. Kolchak)]. Dialog so vremenem. Al’manakh intellektual’noi istorii 77: 94–108.
  4. Bernhard, M., and J. Kubik. 2014. Introduction. In Twenty Years after Communism: The Politics of Memory and Commemoration, edited by M. Bernhard, and J. Kubik, 12–14. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  5. Eremeeva, S.A. 2015. Pamiati pamiatnikov: praktika monumental’noi kommemoratsii v Rossii XIX – nachala XX v. [Memory of Monuments: The Practice of Monumental Commemoration in Russia of the 19th – Early 20th Century]. Moscow: RGGU.
  6. Eremeeva, A.N. 2021. Praktiki memorializatsii antisovetskogo dvizheniia na Yuge Rossii v gody Grazhdanskoi voiny [Practice of Memorialization of the Anti-Soviet Movement in the South of Russia During the Civil War]. Vestnik Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seria 4: Istoriia. Regionovedenie. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia 26 (2): 171–183. https://doi.org/10.15688/jvolsu4.2021.2.13
  7. Eremeeva, A.N., ed. 2022. Gosudarstvennaia monumental’naia politika: opyt, protivorechiia, perspektivy [State Monumental Policy: Experience, Contradictions, Perprospects]. Moscow: Institut Naslediia.
  8. Etkind, A. 2016. Krivoe gore: pamiat’ o nepogrebennykh [Warped Mourning: Stories of the Undead in the Land of Unburied]. Moscow: NLO.
  9. Gajdaj, O. 2018. Kam’janyj gist’. Lenin u Central’nij Ukrai’ni [Stone Guest: Lenin in Central Ukraine]. Kiev: K.I.S.
  10. Gobel, D., and D. Rossell, eds. 2013. Commemoration in America: Essays on Monuments, Memorialization, and Memory. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
  11. Hasian, A., Jr., and N. Paliewicz. 2020. Memory and Monument Wars in American Cities New York, Charlottesville and Montgomery. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
  12. Kasianov, G. 2019. Ukraina i sosedi: istoricheskaia politika. 1987–2018 [Ukraine and the Neighbors: Historical Policy, 1987–2018]. Moscow: NLO.
  13. Khodakovskii, K.N., and V.N. Khodakovskii. 2022. Memorial’naia deiatel’nost’ Kerchenskogo soiuza monarkhistov v Ukrainskii period [Memorial Activities of the Kerch Monarchist Union in the Ukrainian Period]. In Zapiski Kerch’-Enikal’skogo obshchestva istorii i drevnostei [Notes of the Kerch-Yenikal Society of History and Antiquities], edited by S.P. Matveev, 1: 141–269. Kerch’: Kerch’-Enikal’skoe obshchestvo istorii i drevnostei.
  14. Krasilnikova, E.I. 2015. Pomnit’ nel’zia zabyt’? Pamiatnye mesta i kommemorativnye praktiki v gorodakh Zapadnoi Sibiri (konets 1919 – seredina 1941 g.) [Can’t You Forget? Memorable Places and Commemorative Practices in the Cities of Western Siberia (Late 1919 – Mid 1941)]. Novosibirsk: Zolotoi kolos.
  15. Lipman, M.A. 2021. Panteon natsional’nykh geroev kak element simvolicheskoi politiki. Monumental’nye praktiki postsovetskoi Rossii i obshchestvennye predstavleniia o vydaiushchikhsia istoricheskikh lichnostiakh [The Pantheon of National Heroes as an Element of Symbolic Politics: Monumental Practices of Post-Soviet Russia and Public Perceptions of Prominent Historical Figures]. In Simvolicheskie aspekty politiki pamiati v sovremennoi Rossi i Vostochnoi Evrope [Symbolic Aspects of Memory Politics in Modern Russia and Eastern Europe], edited by V.V. Lapin and A.I. Miller, 38–64. St. Petersburg: Izdatel’stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge.
  16. Makiya, K. 2024. The Monument: Art and Vulgarity in Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. London: I.B. Tauris.
  17. McMichael, K. 2009. Sacred Memories: The Civil War Monument Movement in Texas. Denton: Texas State Historical Association.
  18. Miller, A.I. 2019. Rost znachimosti institutsional’nogo faktora v politike pamiati – prichiny i posledstviia [Growing Importance of the Institutional Factor in Memory Policy – Causes and Consequences]. Politiia 3 (94): 87–102.
  19. Miller, A.I., O.Y. Malinova, and D.V. Efremenko, eds. 2023. Politika pamiati v Rossii – regional’noe izmerenie [The Politics of Memory in Russia – Regional Dimension]. Moscow: Institut nauchnoi informatsii po obshchestvennym naukam RAN.
  20. Racheva, E.L. 2022. Inzhavino: kamen’ Antonova, tank Velikoi Otechestvennoi i kust sireni. Pamiat’ o Tambovskom vosstanii v derevniakh Inzhavinskogo raiona [Injavino: the Antonov Stone, The Tank of the Great Patriotic War and the Lilac Bush: Memory of the Tambov Uprising in the Villages of the Injavinsky District]. In Chuzhimi golosami: pamiat’ o krest’ianskikh vosstaniiakh epokhi Grazhdanskoi voiny [By Other People’s Voices: Memory of Peasant Uprisings of the Civil War Era], edited by A.V. Kravchenko and N.A. Lomakin, 26–60. Moscow: NLO.
  21. Rubin, V.A. 2019. Voenno-memorial’noe nasledie kak fenomen rossiiskoi kul’tury: teoreticheskie i istoricheskie aspekty [Military Memorial Heritage as a Phenomenon of Russian Culture: Theoretical and Historical Aspects]. Cheliabinsk: Cheliabinskii gosudarstvennyi institut kul’tury.
  22. Savage, K. 2009. Monument Wars: Washington, D.C., the National Mall, and the Transformation of the Memorial Landscape. Berkeley: University of California Press.
  23. Shilovskii, M.V. 2019. Voina s pamiatnikami ili za pamiatniki: memorializatsiia pamiati o Grazhdanskoi voine v Sibiri [The War with Monuments or for Monuments: Memorializing the Memory of the Civil War in Siberia]. Gumanitarnye problemy voennogo dela 1: 133–138.
  24. Sokolov, D.V. 2024. Rossiia i Krym v XX stoletii. Tragedii. Pamiat’. Nasledie. Istoricheskie issledovaniia. Retsenzii. Stat’i. Interv’iu [Russia and Crimea in the 20th Century: Tragedies; Memory; Heritage; Historical Research; Reviews; Articles; Interviews]. Moscow: Traditsiia.
  25. Strigalev, A.A. 1969. Monument i my [Monument and Us]. Dekorativnoe iskusstvo SSSR 11: 3–12.
  26. Tkachenko, D.S. 2017. Zavershenie Kavkazskoi voiny na Severo-Vostochnom Kavkaze v monumental’noi praktike imperskikh vlastei XIX – nachala XX vv. [The End of the Caucasian War in the North-East Caucasus in the Monumental Practice of the Imperial Authorities of the 19th – Early 20th Centuries]. Nauchnaia mysl’ Kavkaza 4: 107–114. https://doi.org/10.23683/2072-0181-2017-92-4-107-114
  27. Upton, D. 2015. What Can and Can’t Be Said: Race, Uplift, and Monument Building in the Contemporary South. New Haven: Yale University Press.
  28. Vertinsky, P., and S. McKey, eds. 2004. Disciplining Bodies in the Gymnasium: Memory, Monument, Modernism. London: Routledge.
  29. Yurchak, A. 2017. Eto bylo navsegda, poka ne konchilos’. Poslednee sovetskoe pokolenie [Everything Was Forever, Until It Was No More: The Last Soviet Generation]. Moscow: NLO.

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML
Download

Copyright (c) 2025 Russian Academy of Sciences